Evidence is for Silly Nannies


The Incredulity of Saint Thomas, Caravaggio, 1602

I would like to post an expanded version of a short article that I originally shared in November 2013. It fits well with the Easter season. The original title is My Very Own Historical Jesus and can also be found in the archives in its original form. Please feel free to comment.

My Very Own Historical Jesus

For the good Christian, the four Gospels of the New Testament are central to belief in Jesus. These gospels (the Christian revelation) are often referred to as the canonical gospels to distinguish them from the many other gospels and writings that belong to forms of Christianity that did not survive or, for other reasons were not included in the Bible.


Doubt of Thomas, Rembrandt, 17th century

The canonical Gospel we know as The Gospel According to John contains over a dozen stories not found in the three earlier Gospels.

The most startling of these stories is that of the apostle Thomas who would not believe his friends and peers who claimed that Jesus had come back from the grave and was alive.

John’s story tells us that shortly following this, Jesus made a special appearance and invited Thomas to touch him, and John, then, gives the moral of the story: ‘believing in Jesus because you have evidence is not Christianity’.


Thomas the Apostle, 14th century icon

This is a statement that has been overlooked by some portion of every form of Christianity that has come and gone since the creation of the Gospel of John; Christianity is not based on the believer’s connection to the historical Jesus.

There has been a call to belief without evidence ever since the inception of Christianity. But the modern believer is faced with an even greater problem, perhaps a new problem, if they need Jesus to be a historical person.

For some students, the scientific investigation into religious behavior and practice may present, for the first time in their lives, an interpretation of religion not in accord with traditional doctrine.


Gospel fragment, 3rd century

Contemporary analytical approaches to the study of the emergence of Christianity represent an honest pursuit of knowledge of the past. But often, these studies call into question the unchallenged beliefs of the adherent.

This is not unique to secular studies, but is a source of tension within all religious communities who are devoted to studying their own history. related post : I knew a guy who knew a guy…

The story of the founder and origin of a religion is part of the sacred narrative of a religion; the believer often accepts this story as history. But, when seeking the beginnings of religion, we find that there is very little historical information outside of the traditions that transmit the sacred narratives.

Take your pick from among any of the world’s religions; concerning the claims of their origins, not one has the kind of corroborating evidence you would ask for in any pursuit of historical truth.


The Incredulity of Saint Thomas, Caravaggio, 1602

This lack of information is by no means evidence that the events in the narrative are necessarily untrue; however, the student of religion will recognize, quite quickly, that the isolated and insular nature of sacred narrative applies to all the religions of the world.

Among the more well-known religions, these narratives include the story of miracles, execution and resurrection of Jesus for the Christian, the visitation of an Angel and recitation of the Qur’an to Muhammad and the life of Muhammad for the Muslim, the life and sayings of the Buddha, the life and sayings of the Mahavira for the Jain, the life and sayings of Zarathustra in Zoroastrianism, and the life of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Moses and the sacred history of the ancient Hebrews in Judaism.


Moses, Rembrandt, 1659

In Hinduism, the sacred narrative consists of the revealed nature of the Vedas, Upanishads and the epic Mahabharata and Ramayana histories, in Confucianism the life and sayings of Confucius and Mencius, the sayings of Lao-Tzu and the Daozang for the Taoist, and the life and sayings of Nanak, the ten Sikh Gurus and the succession of the Guru Granth Sahib for the Sikh.

All of the origin-stories from these traditional narratives are, at times, masterful, moving, rewarding and often edifying chronicles of humanity searching, speculating and, in some cases, finding meaning.


Lao Tzu departs from China, 19th century painting

Indisputably, all are worth knowing, and the study of these traditions belongs to the life-long pursuit of the serious student of religion. But none were meant as history – not in the sense that you or I could ever mean it.

see origins, for further discussion

Leave a comment

Filed under Christianity, Origins, Religious Controversy, Revelation

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s